Folly and wisdom in the college commencement season
Doing not dreaming. Getting the small stuff right. And spare us the lectures on privilege.
Annapolis, Maryland – Right this moment, the Blue Angels (pictured above) are
thundering over my backyard as the pilots practice for the U.S. Naval Academy
graduation later this week. Virtually anyone who sees these six fast movers silhouetted
against a clear sky feels a sense of wonder and respect. The planes, the pilots - this is
genius and accomplishment and power, all at once.
It's Commissioning Week in Annapolis, a version of the big moment for college seniors
all over the nation and an ideal time to reflect on achievement and equally
important, to the task of finding the subsequent career road ahead. And the one milestone right now,
being shared by every graduate all over the nation is the college commencement address.
During all the past days and years, I’ve been - like you - to a fair share of graduations at all scholastic
levels, From all of these experiences, ole unfiltered Nellie has observed that there are essentially
two kinds of speakers: Those who have actually achieved something concrete and impressive
in their lives. And those who haven’t. Hence, grads receive folly from the latter - and
wisdom from the former.
***
Let's take the latter first. Alas, my own graduation years ago from – let’s call the institution
Faber College - featured an obscure United Nations’ official as the
Commencement speaker. He was “excited” to tell us every detail about
his simply fascinating bureaucratic career and his “heroic” fight at the State
Department and the UN against the long march of American imperialism and
capitalism. He was of the academic class, aglow in his smug
“courage.”
"That fellow seemed rather high on himself,” my mild-mannered father observed
afterwards. Yep, Dad - a successful self-made man who at age 15 worked in a
Union Carbide vanadium mine in the Sierra Mountains and at age 18 took part in
the invasions of Iwo Jima and of Okinawa, later spending months patrolling the streets
of Tokyo with a rifle as part of the Occupation force. All this, even as the UN was being
formed in San Francisco and Dr. Bureaucrat was patrolling library shelves at
Big Bad State. Hey, who knew?! My laid-back old man - both an imperialist and a capitalist!
This obscene tone of self-righteousness had not dissipated when years
later, it was time for my eldest son to graduate from Faber. His commencement
speaker was a "brave" immigrant Nigerian poet (why yes, she told us she was and no, you
cannot make this stuff up) and just a few moments into her remarks she casually informed
the crowd: “If you were born a straight white male or female, well, congratulations,
you hit the jackpot.”
There was an instant and collective audience-wide cringe.
No worry - our poet blindly plowed on in the same fashion:to tell our sons and daughters
".…you need to stand for social justice...fight privilege...empower the marginalized and
voiceless…remake America…”
Oh dear.
Please let me understand this You fled the grinding squalor of Lagos to arrive penniless in
tranquil New England - with its empowering indoor plumbing - and received free American
largesse - all to to tell us this? And is it your “bravery” or total lack of self-awareness at such a
celebratory event to immediately insult 80 percent of your audience? Yeah, you know, those
sad sack parents and alums who have collectively contributed to the institution’s national
preeminence and financial security so that full tuition and board are gifted, ahem, to the
socially justified 20 percent.
By midpoint of her speech it was
deja vu all over again:
The bleacher seats were almost half empty,
duplicating what had occurred during my graduation decades ago. All those loathsome jackpot winners
had left and gathered elsewhere. Being able to ignore the infantile was, well, their privilege.
***
Hence, the folly. The limited, somewhat incoherent speeches come from the mediocrities. It's
wisdom that emanates from those who have firmly engaged the world,
performed at the tough jobs, have hit and overcome the obstacles and have succeeded.
Here are three…
An absolute knock-out speech was given by Shonda Rhimes at Dartmouth College
in 2014. Rhimes is a famous American television screenwriter, best known as a
showrunner - creator, head writer, and executive producer of numerous popular
television and movie productions.
She was blunt – she told grads to stop dreaming and start doing. “The world has
plenty of dreamers. And while they are busy dreaming, the really happy people, the
really successful people, the really interesting, engaged, powerful people, are busy
doing. So ditch the dream and be a doer, not a dreamer. Whether or not you know
what your ‘passion’ might be. The truth is, it doesn't matter. You don't have to
know. You just have to keep moving forward. You just have to keep doing
something, seizing the next opportunity, staying open to trying something new."
Bang! Ditch the introspection – get moving!
***
A second favorite was Admiral William McRaven's University of Texas
commencement address, again in 2014. He spoke about his first days of Navy
SEAL training:
“Every morning we were required to make our bed to perfection, a mundane task. It
seemed a little ridiculous at the time, particularly in light of the fact that were
aspiring to be tough battle-hardened SEALs, but the wisdom of this
simple act has been proven to me many times over. If you make your bed every
morning you will have accomplished the first task of the day.... by the end of the day,
that one task completed will have turned into many tasks completed. Making your
bed will also reinforce the fact that little things in life matter. If you can’t do the little
things right, you will never do the big things right.”
Doing, not dreaming. Getting the small stuff right. Two of the most important
pieces of advice for that road ahead, whether you’re five-years old or 22.
***
As I noted, this is Commissioning Week here in Annapolis and it recalls my third
favorite commencement speech,. It was given by President Trump at my middle son’s
2018 graduation from the Naval Academy. Yeah yeah, whatever your thoughts about the man
and his personality and career, he met the moment in Annapolis and exceeded it.
The audience of parents and friends sitting in Navy-Marine Corps
Stadium, knew what the graduating Midshipmen had endured for four grueling
years: No-excuse military discipline, austere barracks life, four straight summers of training
deployments and mandatory softball courses like Electrical Engineering, Calculus
and Thermodynamics.
Twenty percent of the entering class never made it to graduation because unlike
the “safe spaces” of Faber, failure at USNA has consequences: Goodbye. Seventy-five
percent of the class (including Nellie Junior) were STEM majors. Unlike Faber,
there were no majors in Latinx Studies. These Mids would
soon be in the brutal real world, leading men and women all over the globe, some of them
in charge of ordnance (like Junior) that could reduce a hundred voiceless and
marginalized bad guys to ashes in a social justice instant.
Simple and profound, the President brought it in hard and fast to the Midshipmen.
“You have taken the path of hard work and sweat and sacrifice….the word
impossible does not exist for you because the Navy never quits. You are now
leaders in the most powerful and righteous force on the face of the planet!”
Thankfully, no pathetic shots at capitalism from a third-level career bureaucrat
drone; no remaking of America from a fatuous Third World immigrant.
Just pure sound and fury: “You’re among the finest people anywhere in the world,
the smartest, the strongest! You know you will make us proud. You are warriors.
You are fighters! You are champions!”
Simple, uplifting - a recognition of achievement. Stirring words recognizing these grads
and by association all college seniors, with deserved praise for the award of their four-year degree.
And then to drive it home, oh man, here they came. I can feel and hear the tremendous blast
right now as I heard it eight years ago. Practically touching the rim of Navy-Marine Corps
Stadium is the unbelievable phalanx of the Blue Angels streaking over the crowd at 200 mph,
apt symbols of endeavor and accomplishment and the road ahead.
####
Check out the ultimate Faber College tale: When the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor: Animal House in Western Intellectual Thought at https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0GSZCMNYY?ref=sp_email










